Offense / Defense Village Build

[DeletedUser]

Try them against maybe 2 or 3 different offensive builds that you can think of. Same province, no pally.

 

[DeletedUser]

It's a misunderstanding. I still meant that they fight with 100% faith. I probably shouldn't have included the no church part. What I mean is that it was a village with no church so that you now have an additional farm space. Can you run the simulations again except this time with 100% faith? Take your time, no rush.

 

[DeletedUser430]

Try them against maybe 2 or 3 different offensive builds that you can think of. Same province, no pally.

Here you go:

100% combat strength:

1st Build:

2nd Build:

I have come to the conclusion that defense wins every time lol.

 

[DeletedUser]

Perfect, it holds up well. Much appreciated once again.

 

[DeletedUser430]

Not a problem.

 

[DeletedUser]

coolnite7 can you test some battle with paladin item and same battle without item? probably try multiple times to get similar luck. Also one where only attacker have item, one where only defender have it and one where both have items, like axe and spear. Anyway to me seems that's there's items barely give any effect or maybe I just think so

 

[DeletedUser430]

Okay I will test sometime today for you.

 

[DeletedUser]

3600 axes, 1500 LC, 750 MA, 230 rams --->Church Village
vs.
7000 sp, 2000HC

Whoops, this was not meant to be spear's attacking was it

 

[DeletedUser430]

opps I'm very sorry for that I will redo the attack.


Corrected:
3600 axes, 1500 LC, 750 MA, 230 rams --->Church Village
vs.
7000 sp, 2000HC

 

[DeletedUser1288]

Coolnight7, would you be able to run me some numbers please?

4500 Spears, 4500 Swords, 3000 archers, 1250 HC and 150 Trebuchet
V
19500 axe and 300 rams


3250 HC and 150 Trebuchet
V
19500 axe and 300 rams


4500 Spears, 4500 Swords, 3000 archers, 1250 HC and 150 Trebuchet
V
3250 Berserker's and 300 rams


3250 HC and 150 Trebuchet
V
3250 Berserker's and 300 rams

Thanks

Ninja

 

[DeletedUser430]

Ninja Khan here you go:


4500 Spears, 4500 Swords, 3000 archers, 1250 HC and 150 Trebuchet
vs
19500 axe and 300 rams

3250 HC and 150 Trebuchet
vs
19500 axe and 300 rams

4500 Spears, 4500 Swords, 3000 archers, 1250 HC and 150 Trebuchet
vs
3250 Berserker's and 300 rams

3250 HC and 150 Trebuchet
vs
3250 Berserker's and 300 rams

 

[DeletedUser]

Question
how many terbuchets would you recommend for a defensive stronghold ?

 

[DeletedUser430]

Question
how many terbuchets would you recommend for a defensive stronghold ?

Depends on your defensive setup. Personally I really like this last defensive setup now the question is how long would these builds actually take which could be the problem. But 150 seems like a solid number.

 

[DeletedUser]

lets say that you had all the time in the world (I realize thats not true in war time but still), 150 is still the best bet?

 

[DeletedUser1288]

Coolnite7 thanks for fast response

Edit: Berserker's where outnumbered why didnt they do more damage? it is outnumbered in power, if so by how much? twice as much or just 1% more in power

 

[DeletedUser]

The berserkers caused pretty much the same damage as axeman despit being outnumbered. Do the double bonus strength actually work?

 

[DeletedUser]

I know with the update to 1.6, they said that siege weapons now are attached to the larger grouping of attacking troops to lessen their losses. However, do they still require infantry escorts to prevent 100% losses?

Coolnite, could you run a couple scenarios for me against a defending village with level 20 wall?

1) 2188 LC, 1750MA, and 250 rams vs your pick of full defense village.
2) The above vs a defense build that is something like 20% full (I want to see if 100% of rams still die)

No rush, whenever you get time. Appreciate your help.

 

[DeletedUser430]

1) 2188 LC, 1750MA, and 250 rams vs your pick of full defense village:

2) The above vs a defense build that is something like 20% full (I want to see if 100% of rams still die):

 

[DeletedUser]

Thanks coolnite. So it seems like an infantry escort is no longer needed with rams. Therefore, the fastest, and still effective, nuke is now a pure cavalry with rams....

 

[DeletedUser430]

Thanks coolnite. So it seems like an infantry escort is no longer needed with rams. Therefore, the fastest, and still effective, nuke is now a pure cavalry with rams....

No problem. Anything else just let me know.