trebuchets vs rams/cats

[DeletedUser]

what is the ratio of trebuchets winning against rams and catapults. How many rams or catapults can 1 trebuchet destroy?

 

[DeletedUser]

A trebuchet can destroy 1 ram/catapult.

 

[DeletedUser]

Is this proven? Have you actually tried it?

 

[DeletedUser]

A trebuchet can destroy 1 ram/catapult.

Surely that cannot be correct. The trebuchet requires 12.5x the wood 5x the clay and 10x the iron unit for unit, and requires 2 additional provision space. That would give zero justification for making them for a 1:1 ratio.

 

[DeletedUser430]

This is with no wall:

If there is another ratio/troops you want me to test with please let me know.


Against 2 cats no wall:

 

[DeletedUser]

can you try 50 treb vs 100rams

 

[DeletedUser430]

50 Trebuchets vs 100 Rams no wall:

FYI... Trebuchets are for defense.

 

[DeletedUser]

I see you got it all wrong... Trebuchets should be on the defender side >.

 

[DeletedUser430]

lol I'm just doing what guys asked. If you have a combination you want me to try let me know and I will post results.

 

[DeletedUser]

can you try 50 trebs as defender vs 100 rams as attacker.

Thank you

 

[DeletedUser430]

1st: Wall 0 ---> 100 rams vs 50 trebuchets

2nd Wall 0 ---> 100 Cats vs 50 trebuchets

 

[DeletedUser]

Now we all know its not a 1:1 as others thought it would be.

Thanks coolnite7

 

[DeletedUser]

However, won't 100% of attacking siege weapons die if not accompanied by infantry, or was that a bug that was fixed?

 

[DeletedUser]

coolnite can you try putting some axes along with those rams/cats to see the difference.